← All writings
Writings

Fed's Waller Proposes Alternative to Forward Guidance

By Gurjas Singh Batra · 14 Oct 2026 · Originally on LinkedIn

Fed Chair Warsh wants the Fed to stop guiding markets. Governor Waller has a proposal to do it without the vol.

Here's the problem

At Jackson Hole, Chair Warsh made clear that forward guidance in a stable economy is unwelcome. His core argument is a "hall of mirrors" effect: the Fed guides the market, then reads the market as if it were independent. Asset prices become indicators of a guided yield curve, not the real economy. (For traders: he wants you to "start learning to play the ball, not the referee.")

The catch? Guidance cuts vol. Remove it, and vol rises, and so do hedging costs. That's a major doodoo for market participants.

Here's Waller's proposed fix

Last week in Istanbul, Governor Waller floated a middle path: tell the market how much rates are expected to change over a set interval (say 6 months), but not the path.

My take

  1. It solves two issues at once: reduces vol over the ultra short-term, while still limiting crowding risk since the rate path stays uncertain.
  2. Long-duration prices, like the 10y yield (a key indicator for the Fed), would largely remain unscathed.
  3. Waller stresses that monetary policy is still not predetermined. That smells like BS, because the market will jump to conclusions even with a half-SEP.

So is a half-SEP just forward guidance with better branding? Curious what rates traders and macro folks think.

#FederalReserve #FixedIncome #Rates #MonetaryPolicy #Macro

Discuss on LinkedIn ↗