Fed's Waller Proposes Alternative to Forward Guidance
Fed Chair Warsh wants the Fed to stop guiding markets. Governor Waller has a proposal to do it without the vol.
Here's the problem
At Jackson Hole, Chair Warsh made clear that forward guidance in a stable economy is unwelcome. His core argument is a "hall of mirrors" effect: the Fed guides the market, then reads the market as if it were independent. Asset prices become indicators of a guided yield curve, not the real economy. (For traders: he wants you to "start learning to play the ball, not the referee.")
The catch? Guidance cuts vol. Remove it, and vol rises, and so do hedging costs. That's a major doodoo for market participants.
Here's Waller's proposed fix
Last week in Istanbul, Governor Waller floated a middle path: tell the market how much rates are expected to change over a set interval (say 6 months), but not the path.
My take
- It solves two issues at once: reduces vol over the ultra short-term, while still limiting crowding risk since the rate path stays uncertain.
- Long-duration prices, like the 10y yield (a key indicator for the Fed), would largely remain unscathed.
- Waller stresses that monetary policy is still not predetermined. That smells like BS, because the market will jump to conclusions even with a half-SEP.
So is a half-SEP just forward guidance with better branding? Curious what rates traders and macro folks think.
#FederalReserve #FixedIncome #Rates #MonetaryPolicy #Macro
Discuss on LinkedIn ↗